Filosofia

Special Issue of Res Philosophica on Moral Nonnaturalism (Essay Prize: $3,000)

Guest Editor: Terence Cuneo (University of Vermont)

Deadline for Submission: April 1, 2014

Call for Papers

Res Philosophica invites papers on the topic of moral nonnaturalism for the 2014 Res Philosophica Essay Prize. The author of the winning paper will receive a prize of $3,000 and publication in the special issue of the journal on the same topic. Submissions for the prize will be automatically considered for publication in the journal's special issue unless otherwise requested.

Description

The recent history of moral nonnaturalism has been both tumultuous and unpredictable. In the early 20th century, thanks to the work of philosophers such as G. E. Moore and W. D. Ross, nonnaturalism was arguably the dominant metaethical position in Anglo-American philosophy. By mid-century, however, the view had fallen into disfavor, eclipsed by various versions of expressivism and moral naturalism. Indeed, by century's end, most philosophers had given up nonnaturalism for dead. The view seemed to be of historical interest only.

Few, then, could have predicted that nonnaturalism would receive fresh and vigorous defenses in the early 21st century. Philosophers such as Russ Shafer-Landau, Ralph Wedgwood, David Enoch, and David Parfit each offered book-length defenses of the view, developing the case that moral nonnaturalism is a far more resilient, resourceful, and plausible position than most had assumed.

While nonnaturalism is now, once again, a view that philosophers take very seriously, challenges remain. Some of these challenges concern the view's ontological commitments: How ought we to understand what a nonnatural property (or fact) is? What are the best reasons for holding that moral features (or facts) are not reducible to natural features (or facts)? Are these reasons persuasive? Moreover, what should nonnaturalists say in response to the charge that their view requires us to believe that ontologically discontinuous entities such as natural and nonnatural facts bear necessary connections to one another?

Other challenges concern the view's epistemological commitments: Given the fact that our moral views have been heavily influenced by contingent cultural, historical, and evolutionary forces, how could nonnaturalists plausibly hold that we reliably track the moral truths? Moreover, nonnaturalists have tended to defend intuitionist views in moral epistemology, maintaining that some moral propositions are self-evident. To what extent, though, is nonnaturalism committed to a version of ethical intuitionism? And are these views defensible?

Still other challenges are broadly semantic: If nonnatural features (or facts) do not enter into the causal flow of nature, how could we get them in mind or refer to them? Are nonnaturalists committed to broadly descriptivist accounts of reference? Or can they join forces with naturalists in championing nondescriptivist accounts of reference?

Guidelines

These are just a sample of the sorts of issue that submissions might address. Papers that address other topics in the neighborhood are welcome.

All papers will be triple anonymously reviewed. Please format your submission so that it is suitable for anonymous review. (Instructions available here.)

Papers may be up to 12,000 words long (including footnotes).

We accept pdf and Microsoft Word documents. Papers may be submitted in any standard style, but authors of accepted papers will be required to edit their papers according to the journal's style, which follows The Chicago Manual of Style (16th edition). Style instructions are available here.

Please use the online submission form for submitting your essay, available here.

- Can The Social Contract Be Signed By An Invisible Hand? Guest Editors: Geoffrey Brennan, Bernd Lahno
The title of this special topic in RMM is borrowed from a 1978 paper of Hillel Steiner in which he argues against Robert Nozick’s invisible hand conception of the emergence of the state. Steiner believes that central institutions of social order such...

- Society For The Philosophic Study Of The Contemporary Visual Arts
Central and Pacific Division APA Meetings, 2014 The Society for the Philosophic Study of the Contemporary Visual Arts (SPSCVA) invites papers to be presented at its divisional meetings held in conjunction with the Central & Pacific Division Meetings...

- Methods For Modalities
Lake Placid, New York June 9, 2013 http://www.cs.famaf.unc.edu.ar/~careces/M4M/ThemeThe workshop series Methods for Modalities (M4M) aims to bring together researchers interested in developing algorithms, verification methods and tools...

- Teorema Essay Prize For Young Scholars
The Spanish Philosophy journal teorema is pleased to announce an essay competition for young scholars. The winner will receive 1500€, and the essay will be published and acknowledged as winner in the journal. Topic: Self-knowledge Applicants must be...

- Sixth Annual Cambridge Graduate Conference On The Philosophy Of Mathematics And Logic
19th - 20th January 2013 Keynote speakers: Vann McGee and Crispin Wright Please visit our web page to register, and for further details: http://www.phil.cam.ac.uk/news_events/camgradphilconf.html CALL FOR PAPERS: We invite papers from graduate students,...

Filosofia